Legal Cost Specialists

Morgan v Llandow Metals – £160,000 costs saving

Gibbs Wyatt Stone recently secured a costs saving of approximately £160,000 in the case of Morgan v Llandow Metals (Newport County Court).

The Claimant’s solicitors presented a Bill of Costs for approximately £160,000. An offer of £100,000 was made on behalf of the Defendant supported by an interim payment in the same sum. The offer was rejected and at this stage GWS were instructed to assist. It became apparent that there were serious problems relating to the claim for costs. These centred around myriad potential breaches of the Conditional Fee Agreement Regulations 2000 as well as serious concerns over the authenticity of the CFA document itself. The Defendant’s offer was withdrawn on the advice of GWS. Detailed assessment proceedings were commenced and the matter was referred to a Regional Costs Judge.

There followed four preliminary hearings to deal with the directions of the assessment proceedings, given the complex issues that arose, prior to the matter even being listed for a detailed assessment hearing. Specialist costs counsel acted for the Claimant and GWS for the Defendant. The matter was eventually listed for a preliminary two-day hearing to deal with some of the allegations concerning the authenticity of the CFA. However, shortly before the hearing, the Claimant’s solicitors agreed to drop their claim for costs in its entirety, repay the £100,000 and make a substantial contribution to the Defendant’s costs of assessment.

Although the facts of this case were unique, the outcome reflects the technical expertise that GWS can help bring to high value, complex costs litigation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top